All information was accessed through pitt cat for book work. My research goal is to explore the function of the new covenant in the parenesis of hebrews. Wichelns and the cornell tradition of rhetoric as a humane study by everett l. Wichelns judged a rhetorician in terms of preparation, main ideas, credibility, personality, audience and other factors. Watson points out that amos wilder had published a book on biblical rhetoric in 1964. This highly acclaimed book surveys major approaches to rhetorical criticism through significant essays that explain and illustrate them. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, film studies, gender and race issues, and public memory, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and current. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, film studies, gender and race issues, and public memory, the essays in this volume.
In historical usage, a landmark marks a path or a boundary. Wichelns s groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, gender issues, and contemporary political discourse, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and current practice of rhetorical criticism. Wichelns turned students into scholars and teachers in modern rhetorical theory and criticism. List of books and articles about rhetorical criticism. It focused on analyzing the methodology behind a speechs ability to convey an idea to its audience. Wichelns whately on elocution by wayland maxfield parrish renaissance rhetoric and modern rhetoric. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, film studies, gender and race issues, and public memory, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and current practice of rhetorical criticism. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, film studies, gender and race issues, and public memory, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and. Burgchardt and jones, readings on rhetorical criticism, 5 ed.
Recipient woolbert research award, 1987, winanswichelns book award, 1990, ehninger research award, 1991, elizabeth andersch award, university ohio, 2004. Wichelns observed, we have not much serious criticism of oratory. A comprehensive and uptodate introduction to the analysis of public rhetoric, modern rhetorical criticism teaches readers how to examine and interpret rhetorical situations, ideas, arguments, structure, and style. She is has served as the editor of the quarterly journal of speech and has received the francine merritt award for contributions to women, the national communication association distinguished scholar award, the ehninger award for distinguished rhetorical scholarship, the winanswichelns book award, the charles woolbert award for scholarship of. Wichelns s groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to recent representatives of feminist criticism, close textual analysis, and postmodernism, these essays reflect the historical development, diversity, and practice of rhetorical criticism. Wichelns the rhetoric of hitlers battle 1939 kenneth burke lincolns first inaugural 1954 marie hochmuth nichols lord thomas erskine. Tozer scholar macalester college, 1958, tozer fellow, 1959. Collectively, the forty classic and contemporary essays in this book are. Speakers personality character of the speaker how the audience views a speaker audience major ideas. Wichelns the literary criticism of oratory in 1925.
Rhetorical criticism analyzes the symbolic artifacts of discoursethe words, phrases, images, gestures, performances, texts, films, etc. Rhetorical criticism in communication studies download. Wichelns critiqued the biographical approach in an essay entitled the literary criticism of oratory. With an unparalleled talent for distilling sophisticated rhetorical concepts and processes, sonja foss highlights ten methods of doing rhetorical criticism the systematic investigation and explanation of symbolic acts and artifacts. Pdf integrating rhetorical criticism into business communication. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, gender issues, and contemporary political discourse, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and current practice of rhetorical criticism. Purpose, practice, and pedagogy in rhetorical criticism. In fact, it is a common misreading that gives us some insight into how this founding essay has. The speakers mode of arrangement and mode of expression. Its original publication in 1965 created a spirited controversy. Wichelns focused on discovering criticism through rhetoric. Rhetorical criticism, according to wichelns, can include a focus on. There are now many accepted approaches to rhetorical criticism, and the field is expanding as more researchers push the boundaries of what constitutes criticism in literature.
This is a question of how the argument of hebrews works, that is, its rhetorical strategy. Purpose, practice, and pedagogy in rhetorical criticism, kuypers, jim a. The issue of rhetorics effects, i contend, is central to understanding wichelns as well as the later controversy over it when wichelns student, edwin black, sought to move the practice of rhetorical criticism to consider the merit of textual criticism in place of effects. Karlyn kohrs campbell born april 16, 1937, american speech. Criticism then, is a discipline that, through the investigation and appraisal of the activities and products of men, seeks as its end the understanding of man himself. Understanding rhetorical criticism introduction to. Rhetorical criticism references social sci libretexts. Wichelns suggests that it is possible for rhetorical criticism to serve as a preliminary step that can then set up literary criticism.
Sage reference neoaristotelian criticism sage knowledge. Reflections on rhetorical criticism for all intents and purposes, the subfield of rhetorical criticism began with an essay by herbert wichelns, the literary criticism of oratory, published in 1925. Rhetorical criticism is an approach to communication, which constitutes a systematic investigation of symbolic artifacts and analysis and interpretation of persuasive uses of communication. Readings in rhetorical criticism, 4th edition from brand. Wichelns and the cornell tradition of rhetoric as a humane study, by e. A bibliographic synthesis of rhetorical criticism jstor. In the essay titled literary criticism of oratory, wichelns defined rhetoric as persuasive oratory and attempted to distinguish rhetorical criticism from literary criticism. An important collection for scholars and students, this volume surveys major approaches to rhetorical criticism through significant essays that explain and illustrate them. His piece, historical studies of rhetoric and rhetorician is considered the most influential study in the field of speech. Rhetorical theory and criticism in the first half of the 20th century was dominated by neoaristotelian criticism, the tenets of which were grounded in the rhetoric and summed up most clearly in 1925 by herbert wichelns. The effect of the discourse on its immediate hearers 4. Literary criticism focuses on ahistorical features of the text, whereas rhetorical criticism requires a description of the speakers audience. Rhetorical criticism and theory have changed remarkably over the.
Overall, this book is interesting to read, and it provides a nice historical framework to study the discipline. Understanding rhetorical criticism social sci libretexts. Oct 15, 2004 a comprehensive and uptodate introduction to the analysis of public rhetoric, modern rhetorical criticism teaches readers how to examine and interpret rhetorical situations, ideas, arguments, structure, and style. Herbert wichelns addressed neoaristotelianism in his work the literary criticism of oratory. A concern for audience, for intention, and for structure is. Being a constituent part of the term, criticism means the clarification and definition of the theoretical basis of rhetoric. The text covers a wide range of critical techniques, from cultural and dramatistic analysis to feminist and marxist approaches. This has almost always pertained to stylistic matters, especially figures of speech and thought, and matters of genre and form. Wichelns judged a rhetorician in terms of preparation, main ideas. Wichelnss groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent. In this chapter, we will explore both rhetoric and rhetorical criticism. For example, saint augustine analyzed the rhetorical style of the biblical writers, especially paul, in book iv of his work on christian doctrine, and the. Survey of communication studychapter 7 rhetorical criticism. Wichelns s groundbreaking the literary criticism of oratory to very recent essays on visual argument, film studies, gender and race issues, and public memory, the essays in this volume reflect the historical development, diversity, and current practice of rhetorical criticism.
With this broad agenda for critics, wichelns failed to provide them with a method to. Black in rhetorical criticism, defines rhetoric as, discourse that aims to influence 17. My book was intended to redirect that focus, to be one step in the process of moving from biography to rhetorical analysis. Wichelns narrowed down speech critic to 12 topics to be studied. This book is an anthology of landmark essays in rhetorical criticism. Apr 01, 1995 the new edition of this highly acclaimed book, like the previous editions, surveys major approaches to rhetorical criticism through significant essays that explain and illustrate them. Burgchardt, readings on rhetorical criticism, 4th ed.
Landmark essays on rhetorical criticism book, 1993. Herbert wichelns december 29, 1894 march 4, 1973 was an american rhetorician. The routledge reader in rhetorical criticism 1st edition. The literary criticism of oratory a published in 1925, this article represented an early effort to distinguish rhetorical criticism from literary criticism b wichelns offers several contrary characteristics of literary and rhetorical criticism i. Critical rhetoric as political discourse by murphy, john m.
Literary chriticsm is broader and more limited than rhetorical criticism according to wichelns. Rhetorical analysis shows how the artifacts work, how well they work, and how the artifacts, as discourse, inform and instruct, entertain and arouse, and convince and persuade the audience. Saying that rhet crit is narrower and deeper so dont be afraid of those lit crits. In his book rhetorical questions, black places rhetorical criticism against.
Readings in rhetorical criticism, second edition 18916038. Burgchardts readings in rhetorical criticism, to which it adds a complementary effort. In an early 1925 essay on rhetorical criticism, the study of rhetoric was limited to that of speakers and speeches, and included a number of points to which the critic should attend. While maintaining a strategy of ongoing dialogue with both the prospective reader and the texts under scrutiny, the book acknowledges the authors privileged moment of essential identification and represents a step out of the limiting frame of the inherently. This is a book that, almost singlehandedly, freed scholars from the narrow constraints of a single critical paradigm and created a new era in the study of public discourse. Wichelns outlined some of the basic features of the first method of rhetorical criticism, the neoaristotelian approach. If the primary critical task in the 1970s concerned the reconstruction and proliferation of method in the wake of rhetorical criticism.
Bringing together 50 key readings on rhetorical criticism in a single accessible format, the rhetorical criticism reader furnishes instructors with an ideal resource for teaching and practicing the art of rhetorical criticism. Along with the earlytwentiethcentury renewal of interest in classical sources and the publication of multivolume anthologies of speeches wichelns. Duane watson writes, there has always been limited classical rhetorical criticism of the new testament. The book is a bit dated by current research standards. In this edition, several significant new essays from the literature and an updated organization reflect current issues, scholarship, critical practices, and.
12 39 959 1480 972 489 1082 332 1589 1329 266 92 1140 1471 1099 368 1388 1507 986 1438 1361 1261 902 1374 299 1422 1354 458 200 42 1091 405 122 125